2

wherever it takes to...

Is this proper grammar? I've heard,"Whatever it takes to do something", but this type is the first example for me.

...being a writer means going wherever it takes to find “the scale of things...

2
  • I can't find anything ungrammatical in that extract. Commented Sep 3, 2013 at 10:38
  • James below is right(correct). Commented Sep 3, 2013 at 10:47

3 Answers 3

4

Note that the verb isn't necessarily "to go", and the pattern is the same as your "whatever" examples. Wherever replaces Whatever when the verb indicates movement.

I will do whatever it takes to win the competition.

I will eat whatever it takes to win the competition.

I will walk wherever it takes to win the competition.

I will fly wherever it takes to win the competition.


I think you might just be reading it wrongly:

Breaking it up into the following parts might make more sense:

      phrasal verb*      infinitive    
(going wherever it takes)(to find)

* I suppose this might just be two verbs, rather than a phrasal one, but they go together. My terminology might just be wrong. Feel free to edit.

Have a look at some other examples in different tenses

He goes wherever it takes to find food

The dog went wherever it took to seek shelter

The missionary will go wherever it takes to spread the message.

Also, notice that although there are two verbs, only the first matches the number. It stays the same

5
  • But in this example, there's no object after takes...so what'S going on?
    – user41481
    Commented Sep 3, 2013 at 11:57
  • "the scale of things" is the object in that extract. Commented Sep 3, 2013 at 12:00
  • no no, if you mean what you wrote up there, there must be an object after take...like I let my dog go wherever it took me. like that. so what's going on?
    – user41481
    Commented Sep 3, 2013 at 12:02
  • Does the edit, showing the similarities with "whatever it takes" help? Commented Sep 3, 2013 at 12:10
  • Also, there are objects in each of my examples: food, shelter, the message are all the objects of their respective sentences Commented Sep 3, 2013 at 12:11
1

There are no records for the string wherever it takes to in either the Corpus of Contemporary American English or the British National Corpus, and there are no citations that include it in the Oxford English Dictionary. The Corpus of Global Web-Based English has just these two records, the first from the Philippines, the second from Australia:

He taught me to have courage to go wherever it takes to make it.

From wherever it takes to undumb the nation.

It looks ungrammatical to me. Whatever it takes is grammatical, because it means whatever thing (effort, time, energy, money) it takes. You can take a thing, but you can’t, in the same sense, take a place. The difficulty can be resolved by writing ‘being a writer means going wherever necessary to find . . .’

TrevorD’s examples are grammatical because the construction is different. In all three, ‘it takes’ has an object (him in the first and third, you in the second). But wherever is an adverb, and, as such, cannot be the object of takes. Whatever, by contrast, is a pronoun, and can.

1
  • Correct. The it takes in this context is the same as in it takes a screwdriver and a hammer to assemble the furniture. When I say that I'll bring whatever it takes to assemble the furniture, it implies I'll bring a screwdriver and a hammer. The same kind of substitution should be possible with wherever, but does not work for wherever it takes
    – MSalters
    Commented Sep 4, 2013 at 13:13
0

As @JamesWebster has illustrated, the basic phrase is:

[going] wherever [it] takes

and, although it is often followed by an infinite verb (to ...), is not necessarily followed by to.

For example, the following are also examples of the same phrase:

He needs to go wherever the job takes him.
You need to go wherever it takes you.
He followed the path wherever it took him.

So, yes, it is 'grammatical' and a common idiom.

You must log in to answer this question.