English Language & Usage Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for linguists, etymologists, and serious English language enthusiasts. It only takes a minute to sign up.
Sign up to join this community
What part of speech does here have in the following sentence?
I am here.
I say that in that sentence, here must be an adverb because:
My friend contends that here is a noun because the word here is, in this instance, defined as this place, which in Merriam-Webster is the definition for the noun here.
Both you and your friend are incorrect; sorry.
But that's not your fault; you're at a disadvantage,
if you take your definitions of "part of speech" from English books.
They're hopeless; pay no attention to them.
Here is a proximal deictic locative predicate in the sentence
It does not modify the verb am.
It does not modify anything, in fact.
(Be) here is the Predicate in the sentence.
The logical form is
HERE (I)The am is indeed an auxiliary verb, meaning -- if anything -- 'be located (at)'.
Executive Summary: Calling something an "adverb" is a confession of ignorance.
I'm in agreement with John Lawler that here is not an adverb here: as he says, 'It does not modify the verb am.' One has to really stretch the meaning of modify for that not to be true (which some linguists do).
Intuitively, though, here is more closely associated with the noun group (a pronoun in this case) than with the verb - the speaker's location rather than 'how' he is existing. We could compare 'I am cold', where 'am' is obviously a delexical verbal link between subject and some attribute. But 'cold' is adjectival, describing an inherent characteristic, while 'here' expresses the reference of a noun or noun-phrase in the context, rather than attributes (which are expressed by adjectives). We're almost at the definition of determiners here, but there is more semantic content to 'here'. I think that words like 'here', 'there', 'home' (in 'Is he home?' 'He went home') need their own category (and a working name for this is locative / directional particles).
I am not sure how to answer the question. Most of the answerers have given well reasoned and well supported accounts. It is possible that we have to accept there are different, equally valid, ways of slicing up the language, as long as they are internally consistent.
However, the problem of supposed adverbs is not confined to the copula (the verb to be)
Most, if not all, intransitive verbs can be modified by ‘adverbs’.
“Where are you going?” “Over there.” This might be cheating. My exact meaning depends on my pointing into the distance or at a map.
“How do you feel?” “I feel well.”
“How are you?”. “Well.” « Comment allez vous? » « Bien » “Come sta?”. “Bene”. Even «Τι κάνετε;» «Καλά»
French and Italian have different intransitive verbs for how are you: “How are you going”; “How are you standing”. Greek preserves what in ancient Greek gets called the adverbial accusative of an adjective. Literally, “*What are you doing?” “Good things”! We have a similar adverbial usage of the words good and great. This probably originates from American English.
Here and there are certainly deictic words. This just means they are words of showing (from the Greek deiknumi). The word is equivalent to the Latin-derived demonstrative, familiar to British of my generation.
The sentence “I am here” conveys no information other than that someone is claiming to be somewhere. To have its full meaning, we need to have other information, such as prior knowledge (of the identity of the speaker and, for example, of the fact that s/he has been traveling to a destination already known me). Or perhaps I am a small child and my father is pointing at a spot on a plan he has made of the room in which they both are.
None of this changes what I think is the simple fact that at least for everyday users of the language, ‘here’ is a kind of adverb (a demonstrative, or deictic, if you prefer, adverb). It modifies the verb am, just as well can.
"Here" is an adverb in the sentence,
I am here.
As you indicate.
"Here" is a noun in the sentence,
Let's get away from here.
Here's a definition! (Which is adverbial usage.)
In this instance, “here" is a preposition. It is describing where something or someone is.
See this answer to the ELL question: “In “Give it here!”, is “here” a pronoun, adverb, preposition, or what?”
I am here.
I am a student.
I am here in the kitchen.
In the first sentence, am is the main verb meaning exist. In a sentence like I exist here, the word here shows the location and does the function of an adverb of location.
In the second sentence, am is a linking verb so that it does not denote any action other than linking the subject to its complement.
What do here and in the kitchen function in the third sentence other than functioning as adverbs?
Well, I did think that 'here' and 'there,' as most often used, would be adverbs. They modify the verb. They are not adjectives. It did occur to me that they could be prepositions, but the definition of prepositions -- A preposition is a word that shows the relationship between a noun or a pronoun and another word in the sentence -- suggests that they are not: they don't show a relationship at all, and certainly not one between a noun or pronoun and another word in a sentence. By process of elimination, then, as well as the fact that they tell you the location of the verb -- or modify the verb -- I believe 'here' and 'there' are adverbs.
No doubt, "here" is an adverb. But that is not the point. The point is, the "here" in the sentence can be interpreted as an adverbial or a predicative.
For example, in
"He has been in a garden",
is "in the garden" an adverbial phrase or a predicative phrase? I contend that it is a adverbial phrase, as is "here" in the question sentence, because "in the garden" and "here" answers the question of where. Also, "In the garden" and "here" are not a subject complement, namely a predicative, because "is" or "has been" is not a linking verb. They are the verbs that express existence (used to show the position of a person or thing in space or time). [see the 2nd entry of the meanings of "be"in Cambridge Online Dictionary: https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english-chinese-traditional/be]
"Here" is a pronoun and used as the direct object in the sentence. "Here" is referring to an unnamed place. In context, "here" would be easily identified as the place you are standing.
