For example,

— What did you do yesterday?
— I was working.

I presume this is not grammatically correct; however, I often reply in this way (I'm English). Also vice versa: "What were you doing yesterday?" — "I worked."

Does it matter?

3 Answers 3


I was working is certainly a grammatical answer to the question, but whether you say that or I worked depends on the relationship between the speakers, what has gone on previously in the conversation and on what impression you’re trying to give.

If you are asked What were you doing yesterday? or What did you do yesterday? you won’t often reply I was working or I worked. What were you doing yesterday?, for example, can imply a suspicion, or even an accusation. In that case, the reply might well be What do you mean? I wasn’t doing anything yesterday. Similarly, if you’re asked What did you do yesterday? you might reply Um, let me see. First I went to buy a newspaper, then I took the dog for a walk . . .

There can be no single answer to a question like this. Context determines everything.

  • Thanks Barrie, I understand that and I hadn't thought of it in such an interogative way. Excellent. Commented Feb 21, 2013 at 10:45

There is absolutely no reason to reply to a question with the tense and aspect it was given in. There are indeed times when it would be inappropriate:

"What did you do yesterday?"

"I was working, but I left early to go to the doctors."

Here the mixture of past continuous and simple past is the best way to convey the two events we want to include in the answer.

Even the bare progressive, "I was working," has an advantage over the simple past "I worked," in precisely the way that the progressive serves; It includes the information that this took some time, and in the context implies it took up much of the time frame referred to ("yesterday").

We can even imply the past with the future:

"Did you write that report yet?"

"I'm going to do it this afternoon."

Here we respond with a statement about the future, that both entails an answer about the past (it has not been written yet), and provides useful extra information (whether useful to the querent, useful to the answerer in excusing their not having done the task yet, or both).

And of course, simple yes or no answers have no real tense or aspect:

"Did you write that report yet?"


When we've a choice of answering in a matching tense and aspect, or in another, we're slightly more likely to do so just as a matter of mirroring (we change a lot of how we act to match how those we are conversing with act, including a lot of our language choices), but there's absolutely no grammatical rule.

We wouldn't mirror in this way if differing from the question gave a better answer (by whatever definition of better you choose to apply) and we might deliberately not mirror (e.g. answering in a more or less formal register can hint at a disagreement with the querent without expressing it outright). Choosing to mirror when possible, is a style choice available to us, but only one.

  • That's brilliant, thank you very much for taking the time to prepare such an enlightening response. Commented Feb 21, 2013 at 10:43

Grammatically, the correct answer for the question "What did you do yesterday?" is "I worked." But in spoken English it does not matter if you answer like "I was working."

  • 2
    I am sorry, are you saying spoken English is ungrammatical? Perhaps we must first ensure that we are all on the same page about what "grammatical" actually means.
    – RegDwigнt
    Commented Feb 21, 2013 at 9:44
  • @RegDwighт "spoken"? "I was working" is perfectly grammatical in written English, too.
    – Jon Hanna
    Commented Feb 21, 2013 at 10:08
  • @Jon well yes, and then there's that.
    – RegDwigнt
    Commented Feb 21, 2013 at 10:09

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.