2

I am writing up a document for an art exhibit and have found myself a bit confused.

The piece in question is a lidded jar with a stand and handle. The sentence in question is as follows:

Worthy of particular attention are the lidded jars with stand and handle pictured here.

Each jar has one stand and one handle. Is it proper to say "lidded jars with stand and handle," or does this seem to imply an amorphous collection of jars that share a stand and handle? I hesitate to say "lidded jars with stands and handles," as this would imply that multiple stands and handles are attached to each jar.

1

2 Answers 2

0

The singular nouns here represent a whole category that can be linked to the headed plural noun. So you are fine. It takes the groups as a whole.

"The country is full of people with song and dance" shares the same kind of syntax and grammar.

1
  • Mr. Randolph, thank you for your prompt and helpful reply!
    – Liddedjar
    Commented Feb 10, 2013 at 4:23
0

This is another opportunity for using factorization to analyse the structure: Should I place "me" and "I" in the same sentence?.

There are many police officers, who each owns a gun.

can be factorized graphically to:

There are many {a police officer who own a gun}s.

However such a representation has to be written in English as either

  • There are many a police officer who owns a gun.
  • There are many police officers who own a gun.

That is a differentiation from

There are many police officers, who each owns some guns.
There are many {a police officer who own guns}s.

  • There are many a police officer who owns guns.
  • There are many police officers who own guns.
2
  • I still don't understand who is stalking my systemic analyses of the English language by down-voting without explanation. Commented Feb 10, 2013 at 8:55
  • I didn't downvote you, but I have a hard time figuring out whether you are saying all of those things are acceptable or not. "There are many police officers, who each owns some guns" sounds awful to my ears. In short, I think you could probably clarify your answer some.
    – Kit Z. Fox
    Commented Feb 15, 2013 at 13:30

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.