Skip to main content
added 474 characters in body
Source Link
anongoodnurse
  • 55.7k
  • 17
  • 130
  • 207

Language isn't math (or what I would imagine math is) where absolutes are clear and defined.

The purpose of language is to communicate. If communication is not your goal, you can do whatever you want with words, including to write a book that is one long, circular, never ending sentence (it would have no beginning, either.) A person could start wherever they wanted to, and it would be just as incomprehensible (and permissible) as at any different point.

But if you want to communicate, language has to have limitations to be intelligible.

Is there a rule/principle that limits the length of a noun phrase?

There is no rule. One limits a noun phrase or any other aspect of a sentence based on comprehensibility. There are math equations that are completely beyond me, and there are sentences that I have to read several times to understand. The latter are not "wrong".

Noam Chomsky's famous sentence is grammatically correct, but it doesn't really mean anything that reflects our reality.

Colorless green ideas sleep furiously.

Edited to add: As Professor Lawler pointed out, language must be speakable, placing another real limit on it.

Any noun phrase long enough to be unpronounceable within a long human lifetime (say, 100 years) would be ungrammatical.

Language isn't math (or what I would imagine math is) where absolutes are clear and defined.

The purpose of language is to communicate. If communication is not your goal, you can do whatever you want with words, including to write a book that is one long, circular, never ending sentence (it would have no beginning, either.) A person could start wherever they wanted to, and it would be just as incomprehensible (and permissible) as at any different point.

But if you want to communicate, language has to have limitations to be intelligible.

Is there a rule/principle that limits the length of a noun phrase?

There is no rule. One limits a noun phrase or any other aspect of a sentence based on comprehensibility. There are math equations that are completely beyond me, and there are sentences that I have to read several times to understand. The latter are not "wrong".

Language isn't math (or what I would imagine math is) where absolutes are clear and defined.

The purpose of language is to communicate. If communication is not your goal, you can do whatever you want with words, including to write a book that is one long, circular, never ending sentence (it would have no beginning, either.) A person could start wherever they wanted to, and it would be just as incomprehensible (and permissible) as at any different point.

But if you want to communicate, language has to have limitations to be intelligible.

Is there a rule/principle that limits the length of a noun phrase?

There is no rule. One limits a noun phrase or any other aspect of a sentence based on comprehensibility. There are math equations that are completely beyond me, and there are sentences that I have to read several times to understand. The latter are not "wrong".

Noam Chomsky's famous sentence is grammatically correct, but it doesn't really mean anything that reflects our reality.

Colorless green ideas sleep furiously.

Edited to add: As Professor Lawler pointed out, language must be speakable, placing another real limit on it.

Any noun phrase long enough to be unpronounceable within a long human lifetime (say, 100 years) would be ungrammatical.

Source Link
anongoodnurse
  • 55.7k
  • 17
  • 130
  • 207

Language isn't math (or what I would imagine math is) where absolutes are clear and defined.

The purpose of language is to communicate. If communication is not your goal, you can do whatever you want with words, including to write a book that is one long, circular, never ending sentence (it would have no beginning, either.) A person could start wherever they wanted to, and it would be just as incomprehensible (and permissible) as at any different point.

But if you want to communicate, language has to have limitations to be intelligible.

Is there a rule/principle that limits the length of a noun phrase?

There is no rule. One limits a noun phrase or any other aspect of a sentence based on comprehensibility. There are math equations that are completely beyond me, and there are sentences that I have to read several times to understand. The latter are not "wrong".