Skip to main content
formatting of weblink
Source Link
None
  • 4.3k
  • 3
  • 32
  • 50

I don't know why someone downvoted, 39 - I'm having quite a job finding corroboration in online dictionaries for the following.

Some verbs in English have a dual usage, where a transitive usage may be switched to an intransitive one, the direct object becoming the subject:

Bill closed the door - the door closed

Phil broke the window - the window broke

Jill cooked the ham - the ham cooked

Qwill melted the ice in a pan - the ice melted

Will sold his Monet - Will's Monet sold for over $12 million

Such a usage is called the ergative usage.

I'd distinguish this from the middle voice, a similar construction where a property of state rather than an action is being described:

Plastic windows break too easily.

Ice melts at 0 degrees C.

Battery-operated PIR alarms are selling for $12 at the hardware store.

I'm sure that the verb ship can be used ergatively, but it doesn't appear in Wikipedia's lengthy list ( http://en.wiktionary.org/w/index.php?title=Category:English_ergative_verbs&pagefrom=roast#mw-pagesWikipedia's lengthy list ), and the following is the only support I've found for my analysis:

ship: To go aboard a ship ... (AHDEL)

(obviously, to ship = to send by ship is a well-known transitive usage)

I'd add that the meaning of 'ship' (transitive) has been broadened to 'send by, or as if by, ship', and so that of 'ship' (intransitive) has followed, being broadened to 'be sent off'.

I don't know why someone downvoted, 39 - I'm having quite a job finding corroboration in online dictionaries for the following.

Some verbs in English have a dual usage, where a transitive usage may be switched to an intransitive one, the direct object becoming the subject:

Bill closed the door - the door closed

Phil broke the window - the window broke

Jill cooked the ham - the ham cooked

Qwill melted the ice in a pan - the ice melted

Will sold his Monet - Will's Monet sold for over $12 million

Such a usage is called the ergative usage.

I'd distinguish this from the middle voice, a similar construction where a property of state rather than an action is being described:

Plastic windows break too easily.

Ice melts at 0 degrees C.

Battery-operated PIR alarms are selling for $12 at the hardware store.

I'm sure that the verb ship can be used ergatively, but it doesn't appear in Wikipedia's lengthy list ( http://en.wiktionary.org/w/index.php?title=Category:English_ergative_verbs&pagefrom=roast#mw-pages ), and the following is the only support I've found for my analysis:

ship: To go aboard a ship ... (AHDEL)

(obviously, to ship = to send by ship is a well-known transitive usage)

I'd add that the meaning of 'ship' (transitive) has been broadened to 'send by, or as if by, ship', and so that of 'ship' (intransitive) has followed, being broadened to 'be sent off'.

I don't know why someone downvoted, 39 - I'm having quite a job finding corroboration in online dictionaries for the following.

Some verbs in English have a dual usage, where a transitive usage may be switched to an intransitive one, the direct object becoming the subject:

Bill closed the door - the door closed

Phil broke the window - the window broke

Jill cooked the ham - the ham cooked

Qwill melted the ice in a pan - the ice melted

Will sold his Monet - Will's Monet sold for over $12 million

Such a usage is called the ergative usage.

I'd distinguish this from the middle voice, a similar construction where a property of state rather than an action is being described:

Plastic windows break too easily.

Ice melts at 0 degrees C.

Battery-operated PIR alarms are selling for $12 at the hardware store.

I'm sure that the verb ship can be used ergatively, but it doesn't appear in Wikipedia's lengthy list, and the following is the only support I've found for my analysis:

ship: To go aboard a ship ... (AHDEL)

(obviously, to ship = to send by ship is a well-known transitive usage)

I'd add that the meaning of 'ship' (transitive) has been broadened to 'send by, or as if by, ship', and so that of 'ship' (intransitive) has followed, being broadened to 'be sent off'.

added 154 characters in body
Source Link
Edwin Ashworth
  • 87.2k
  • 12
  • 154
  • 272

I don't know why someone downvoted, 39 - I'm having quite a job finding corroboration in online dictionaries for the following.

Some verbs in English have a dual usage, where a transitive usage may be switched to an intransitive one, the direct object becoming the subject:

Bill closed the door - the door closed

Phil broke the window - the window broke

Jill cooked the ham - the ham cooked

Qwill melted the ice in a pan - the ice melted

Will sold his Monet - Will's Monet sold for over $12 million

Such a usage is called the ergative usage.

I'd distinguish this from the middle voice, a similar construction where a property of state rather than an action is being described:

Plastic windows break too easily.

Ice melts at 0 degrees C.

Battery-operated PIR alarms are selling for $12 at the hardware store.

I'm sure that the verb ship can be used ergatively, but it doesn't appear in Wikipedia's lengthy list ( http://en.wiktionary.org/w/index.php?title=Category:English_ergative_verbs&pagefrom=roast#mw-pages ), and the following is the only support I've found for my analysis:

ship: To go aboard a ship ... (AHDEL)

(obviously, to ship = to send by ship is a well-known transitive usage)

I'd add that the meaning of 'ship' (transitive) has been broadened to 'send by, or as if by, ship', and so that of 'ship' (intransitive) has followed, being broadened to 'be sent off'.

I don't know why someone downvoted, 39 - I'm having quite a job finding corroboration in online dictionaries for the following.

Some verbs in English have a dual usage, where a transitive usage may be switched to an intransitive one, the direct object becoming the subject:

Bill closed the door - the door closed

Phil broke the window - the window broke

Jill cooked the ham - the ham cooked

Qwill melted the ice in a pan - the ice melted

Such a usage is called the ergative usage.

I'd distinguish this from the middle voice, a similar construction where a property of state rather than an action is being described:

Plastic windows break too easily.

Ice melts at 0 degrees C.

I'm sure that the verb ship can be used ergatively, but it doesn't appear in Wikipedia's lengthy list ( http://en.wiktionary.org/w/index.php?title=Category:English_ergative_verbs&pagefrom=roast#mw-pages ), and the following is the only support I've found for my analysis:

ship: To go aboard a ship ... (AHDEL)

(obviously, to ship = to send by ship is a well-known transitive usage)

I'd add that the meaning of 'ship' (transitive) has been broadened to 'send by, or as if by, ship', and so that of 'ship' (intransitive) has followed, being broadened to 'be sent off'.

I don't know why someone downvoted, 39 - I'm having quite a job finding corroboration in online dictionaries for the following.

Some verbs in English have a dual usage, where a transitive usage may be switched to an intransitive one, the direct object becoming the subject:

Bill closed the door - the door closed

Phil broke the window - the window broke

Jill cooked the ham - the ham cooked

Qwill melted the ice in a pan - the ice melted

Will sold his Monet - Will's Monet sold for over $12 million

Such a usage is called the ergative usage.

I'd distinguish this from the middle voice, a similar construction where a property of state rather than an action is being described:

Plastic windows break too easily.

Ice melts at 0 degrees C.

Battery-operated PIR alarms are selling for $12 at the hardware store.

I'm sure that the verb ship can be used ergatively, but it doesn't appear in Wikipedia's lengthy list ( http://en.wiktionary.org/w/index.php?title=Category:English_ergative_verbs&pagefrom=roast#mw-pages ), and the following is the only support I've found for my analysis:

ship: To go aboard a ship ... (AHDEL)

(obviously, to ship = to send by ship is a well-known transitive usage)

I'd add that the meaning of 'ship' (transitive) has been broadened to 'send by, or as if by, ship', and so that of 'ship' (intransitive) has followed, being broadened to 'be sent off'.

added 161 characters in body
Source Link
Edwin Ashworth
  • 87.2k
  • 12
  • 154
  • 272

I don't know why someone downvoted, 39 - I'm having quite a job finding corroboration in online dictionaries for the following.

Some verbs in English have a dual usage, where a transitive usage may be switched to an intransitive one, the direct object becoming the subject:

Bill closed the door - the door closed

Phil broke the window - the window broke

Jill cooked the ham - the ham cooked

Qwill melted the ice in a pan - the ice melted

Such a usage is called the ergative usage.

I'd distinguish this from the middle voice, a similar construction where a property of state rather than an action is being described:

Plastic windows break too easily.

Ice melts at 0 degrees C.

I'm sure that the verb ship can be used ergatively, but it doesn't appear in Wikipedia's lengthy list ( http://en.wiktionary.org/w/index.php?title=Category:English_ergative_verbs&pagefrom=roast#mw-pages ), and the following is the only support I've found for thismy analysis:

ship: To go aboard a ship ... (AHDEL)

(obviously, to ship = to send by ship is a well-known transitive usage)

I'd add that the meaning of 'ship' (transitive) has been broadened to 'send by, or as if by, ship', and so that of 'ship' (intransitive) has followed, being broadened to 'be sent off'.

I don't know why someone downvoted, 39 - I'm having quite a job finding corroboration in online dictionaries for the following.

Some verbs in English have a dual usage, where a transitive usage may be switched to an intransitive one, the direct object becoming the subject:

Bill closed the door - the door closed

Phil broke the window - the window broke

Jill cooked the ham - the ham cooked

Qwill melted the ice in a pan - the ice melted

Such a usage is called the ergative usage.

I'd distinguish this from the middle voice, a similar construction where a property of state rather than an action is being described:

Plastic windows break too easily.

Ice melts at 0 degrees C.

I'm sure that the verb ship can be used ergatively, but the following is the only support I've found for this:

ship: To go aboard a ship ... (AHDEL)

(obviously, to ship = to send by ship is a well-known transitive usage)

I'd add that the meaning of 'ship' (transitive) has been broadened to 'send by, or as if by, ship', and so that of 'ship' (intransitive) has followed, being broadened to 'be sent off'.

I don't know why someone downvoted, 39 - I'm having quite a job finding corroboration in online dictionaries for the following.

Some verbs in English have a dual usage, where a transitive usage may be switched to an intransitive one, the direct object becoming the subject:

Bill closed the door - the door closed

Phil broke the window - the window broke

Jill cooked the ham - the ham cooked

Qwill melted the ice in a pan - the ice melted

Such a usage is called the ergative usage.

I'd distinguish this from the middle voice, a similar construction where a property of state rather than an action is being described:

Plastic windows break too easily.

Ice melts at 0 degrees C.

I'm sure that the verb ship can be used ergatively, but it doesn't appear in Wikipedia's lengthy list ( http://en.wiktionary.org/w/index.php?title=Category:English_ergative_verbs&pagefrom=roast#mw-pages ), and the following is the only support I've found for my analysis:

ship: To go aboard a ship ... (AHDEL)

(obviously, to ship = to send by ship is a well-known transitive usage)

I'd add that the meaning of 'ship' (transitive) has been broadened to 'send by, or as if by, ship', and so that of 'ship' (intransitive) has followed, being broadened to 'be sent off'.

Source Link
Edwin Ashworth
  • 87.2k
  • 12
  • 154
  • 272
Loading