Reputation
Top tag
Next privilege 250 Rep.
View close votes
Badges
1 1 8
Impact
~41k people reached

  • 0 posts edited
  • 1 helpful flag
  • 4 votes cast
May
12
awarded  Famous Question
Oct
25
awarded  Citizen Patrol
Oct
23
comment Is spelling part of Language?
Thanks. Totally understand - John Lawler answered (more fully) anyway. The comment (by the same Lawler) makes a sweeping generalization about education in the US that obscures his meaning somewhat though. Education - especially in regard to how things are spelled is not purely locally autonomous. Sorry I can't just delete the question for you though.
Oct
23
awarded  Scholar
Oct
23
accepted Is spelling part of Language?
Oct
23
comment Is spelling part of Language?
Thanks so much. That makes a lot of sense, kind of like how technological developments that come from science are not science even though they may arise from knowledge gained through science. Writing arises from language as a technology to represent it, but is separate from it.
Oct
23
awarded  Student
Oct
23
revised Is spelling part of Language?
added 204 characters in body
Oct
23
comment Is spelling part of Language?
I don't believe I said spelling always did relate to pronunciation. I did say writing and spoken forms of the same language are directly related, but that includes the words actually used as well as the grammatical structure in using those words, not that all spelling is phonetic. What I am saying is that, spelling is related to writing - a form of communication AND therefore a form of language (as I understand it). Wouldn't spelling then be a PART of language - at least those that have a written form?
Oct
23
revised Is spelling part of Language?
added 133 characters in body
Oct
23
revised Is spelling part of Language?
added 374 characters in body
Oct
23
asked Is spelling part of Language?
Oct
3
awarded  Notable Question
Jul
30
awarded  Popular Question
Nov
22
revised Are there regional distinctions in how hiccup/hiccough is spelled?
edited tags
Nov
22
comment Are there regional distinctions in how hiccup/hiccough is spelled?
@ Edwin Ashworth agreed.
Nov
22
revised Are there regional distinctions in how hiccup/hiccough is spelled?
edited tags
Nov
22
awarded  Teacher
Nov
21
revised Are there regional distinctions in how hiccup/hiccough is spelled?
added 4 characters in body
Nov
21
awarded  Editor