417 reputation
211
bio website
location
age 52
visits member for 2 years, 9 months
seen Apr 17 at 0:31
stats profile views 24

jack@realmode.com


Oct
18
awarded  Yearling
Sep
30
awarded  Popular Question
Sep
27
awarded  Commentator
Sep
27
comment Why is there a [sic] in this passage?
For the record, I contacted the author and got the answer.
Sep
23
comment Why is there a [sic] in this passage?
I don't think that could be it, because the word occurred in an orally delivered sermon, not in a piece of writing.
Sep
22
comment Why is there a [sic] in this passage?
I wondered if the authors might be making an editorial comment, but they are all professional scholars, and the book is a high school history text, so it seemed unlikely.
Sep
22
comment Why is there a [sic] in this passage?
The excerpt is from a current textbook, where six highly credentialed academics decided a [sic] was needed, indicating some kind of ENGLISH LANGUAGE mistake in the original passage. I did a bit of googling and asking around, but couldn't determine the error. I thought this site could help, and even find the question interesting. It's apparent that I don't understand the scope of this site, because I certainly don't understand this closing.
Sep
22
asked Why is there a [sic] in this passage?
Aug
2
awarded  Caucus
Dec
13
comment What does “somebody plays things close to the vest” mean?
The link is broken.
Sep
16
comment Is “Sent from my iPhone” correctly punctuated and capitalized?
I don't understand what is wrong with this question.
Aug
16
comment Is “Sent from my iPhone” correctly punctuated and capitalized?
I think it's no coincidence that all those signs use all-caps. These phrases are not trying to be sentences. Nevertheless, thanks for your answer; I like the term telegraphic.
Aug
12
comment “India's army, in numbers, is second only to China's and America's.”
Thank you for the answer but I find the Copenhagen example unconvincing because the subject (it) is second to only one port. The sentence in the Economist has India's Army second to two others.
Aug
12
asked Is “Sent from my iPhone” correctly punctuated and capitalized?
Aug
7
awarded  Yearling
Jul
21
awarded  Scholar
Jul
21
accepted “Nine out of 10”
Jul
21
awarded  Cleanup
Jul
21
revised “Nine out of 10”
rolled back to a previous revision
Jul
20
asked “Nine out of 10”