Reputation
25,365
Next tag badge:
98/100 score
31/20 answers
Badges
1 28 70
Newest
 Nice Answer
Impact
~2.9m people reached

May
1
answered Can I describe time as “organic”?
May
1
comment “Boyfriend” and “girlfriend” usage
@DavidPugh The word "concubine" is used when discussing cultures where polygamy is practiced to mean a lesser wife of inferior status to the man's "primary" wife or wives. To me it sounds like a demeaning thing to call a woman, like, "You're not high class enough to be my wife, but I'd take you as a concubine." :-)
May
1
comment “Boyfriend” and “girlfriend” usage
I don't claim to know the history either. There are lots of things in language that don't have a good logical reason: they just are. @andrewleach In the U.S., women were calling female friends "girlfriends" while men were not calling male friends "boyfriends" for as long as I can remember, way back when homosexuality here was, if not illegal, at least much more frowned on that it is today.
May
1
answered Capitalization in merged company name
May
1
comment What does Ï mean in a play?
It doesn't mean anything. It may, as curiousdanni says, be some problem with the character encoding or some other issue with the creation of the PDF from whatever the original source file was. Or it may just be a typo: somebody accidentally hit an extra key when editing.
May
1
answered Is this a dangling participle? “To use the computer, it need to be powered.”
May
1
answered Is “Next to that” really an alternative to “Additionally” or “Moreover”?
May
1
answered I will offer up a few bits of advice (???)
Apr
30
comment What's the difference between 'mark' and 'grade', in an educational context?
Huh, really? In the US, approximately 40% of grades are A's, 35% are B's, 15% C's, 5% D's, and 5% F's. (See, for example, gradeinflation.com)
Apr
30
answered What's the difference between 'mark' and 'grade', in an educational context?
Apr
24
comment Why doesn't the English language have distinct words to use when talking to elders?
And the change is in the wrong direction to fit that theory. If the language had shifted from using "thou" for lessers and "you" for greaters to using "thou" for everyone, a plausible conclusion would be that the culture had lost respect for the people who used to be called by the more formal word. But in fact it was exactly the opposite that happened. The obvious theory is that people said, in effect, not "Those people don't deserve special respect", but rather "Everyone deserves respect". (I don't suppose that this logic PROVES my point, but I think it is evidence.)
Apr
24
comment Why doesn't the English language have distinct words to use when talking to elders?
"Should be": Who says? By what standard do you say that a language that has different pronouns for different classes of people "right" and a language that does not have this is "wrong"? We could certainly debate whether having such words encourages a civil society, encourages blind obedience to authority, is done so mindlessly that it makes no difference at all, etc. But even if it's true that it accomplishes some worthy goal, it's quite a leap from there to saying that that's the only way to accomplish this worthy goal, or that there might not be other competing goals that are equally worthy.
Apr
24
comment Why doesn't the English language have distinct words to use when talking to elders?
Hmm, to say that politeness only "counts" if you reserve it for special people, and that being respectful to everyone is morally equivalent to being rude to everyone, as long as either one is done equally ... just, no. One can certainly imagine a person who gives candy to people he likes and punches people he doesn't like in the face. One can imagine a person who gives candy to everyone. One can imagine a person who punches everyone in the face. The last two are not equivalent and indistinguishable just because he is treating everyone the same.
Apr
24
comment Are “Lord” and “God” interchangeable?
@Xantix It's actually pretty common to talk about "Judeo-Christian beliefs", so I think talking about "the Judeo-Christian God", meaning the concept of God as understood by Jews and Christians, would be quite accurate. Of course Jews and Christians would say that he is the God of everyone and not just of them, but it is their idea, conception, understanding of God.
Apr
6
comment Is it offensive to call a redhead a “ginger”?
Hmm, actually I think there IS a certain amount of slavery associated with red hair: red hair is generally associated with the Irish and the Scots, and both groups were oppressed by the English. The Irish in Britain were oppressed more recently than blacks, I think. Whether that history comes to people's minds when someone says "ginger" I have no idea. As others have noted, as an American I have only heard the word from UK sources.
Mar
25
comment Is “women men girls love meet die” a valid sentence?
... sense, is nevertheless difficult to understand. Once you introduce elements into the sentence that don't make sense, you create an entirely different issue: Is the sentence difficult to understand because we expect sentences to be rational and coherent and so we stumble over the illogic? Or is the sentence difficult to understand because of the "layered" construction? If I said, "Orange Sally is fast", you'd likely stumble over the meaning for entirely different reasons. It doesn't make sense, so you struggle to extract meaning, even though the grammar is simple and straightforward.
Mar
25
comment Is “women men girls love meet die” a valid sentence?
Hmm, I agree that the "die" part is jarring and doesn't really make sense. There are certainly men that girls love. These men presumably often meet women -- assuming here that we're distinguishing "women" from "girls". Up to that point it looks like we are moving toward a coherent meaning, something about what happens when mature women meet men who are loved by young girls. But they die? That doesn't seem to make sense. In this sense I think I agree that the sentence is poorly constructed. It would be more effective to show that a sentence that, if successfully parsed, makes complete ...
Mar
23
awarded  Nice Answer
Mar
20
awarded  Nice Answer
Mar
17
comment What is a term for something unwanted but which cannot be ignored?
@HotLicks To an extent. But if, say, someone keeps kicking you in the shins, you can try to ignore them, you can pretend to ignore them, but you can't just not notice that they're doing it. Also, just because you CAN ignore something doesn't mean that you do. So I think it's fair to talk about things that a person is TRYING to ignore but which is difficult to ignore.