Tell me more ×
English Language & Usage Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for linguists, etymologists, and serious English language enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.
up vote 0 down vote favorite

Someone told me: "Here 'earth' means 'cave'. 'Man from earth' means 'caveman'."

I doubt that. I can't find any dictionary supporting that explanation.

However, the word "earth" does have multiple meanings, such as "the planet Earth" and "mud, soil". I wonder which one is the most suitable here.

Some points I notice:

Here "Earth" is capitalised, but nouns in titles are always capitalised, so it does not mean "Earth" must refer to "the planet Earth".

Besides, there is no "the" before "Earth". For which meaning(s) can the article before "earth" be dropped?

Edit:

The "soil/mud" meaning is explainable. A cave can be made from soil, though I always thought cavemen lived in stone cave.

If "Earth" does mean "the planet Earth", what is the meaning of this title? Everyone is from the planet Earth.

share|improve this question
2  
I think it means a man from planet Earth. www.manfromearth.com/index.html – JLG Jun 4 '12 at 12:55
The link does not seem to include any explanation on the title. – Betty Jun 4 '12 at 13:01
I didn't expect a -1. I think this question shows research effort. >_< – Betty Jun 4 '12 at 13:22
1  
The main character is an "immortal who has walked the earth for 14,000 years." I guess he would have the right to be identified as closely to Earth as anyone. Also, I think the writers of movie titles want you to think, which you obviously have been. (I wasn't the downvote BTW.) – JLG Jun 4 '12 at 13:31
5  
This is very close to literary analysis, as it's the title of an artistic work. Titles are often chosen to be deliberately thought-provoking and ambiguous. It could simply be the case that the author wanted many different possibly interpretations. – Mark Beadles Jun 4 '12 at 15:38
show 3 more comments

5 Answers

up vote 4 down vote

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0756683/

Although the film does include the eponymous Man as a caveman, the word earth never refers to a cave, even though a fox's earth is its burrow. In this case Earth does refer to the planet, and it's quite normal for the planet's name to be used without the definite article.

I'll leave it to others to explain when one uses "Earth" and "the Earth" (I can't!)

share|improve this answer
1  
The imdb page does not seem to include any explanation on the title. For other part of the answer, I agree. – Betty Jun 4 '12 at 13:02
1  
@Betty: It is very rare that any explanation is ever given for any title. If there is one, IMDB is not likely to have it. – Mitch Jun 4 '12 at 13:15
Just want to say, I have checked the imdb page before I posted the question. :) – Betty Jun 4 '12 at 13:21
up vote 4 down vote

"Here 'earth' means 'cave'.

As far as I know "earth" never means "cave". It is "soil/mud" or "planet Earth", but never anything even remotely resembling "cave".

I doubt that. I can't find any dictionary supporting that explanation.

As far as I can tell, that "someone" is mistaken. Ask him/(her?) to support this statement with something.

Besides, there is no "the" before "Earth"

In this case "Earth" is a name of the planet. You do not use "the" with names. "Mars", "London", "William" are used without "the", so "Earth" is also used without "the" when it means "planet Earth".

share|improve this answer
1  
My print dictionary lists one meaning for earth as: any hole in the ground in which a fox takes refuge. Likewise, meaning #3 in this online dictionary is similar: a hole in the ground where an animal such as a fox lives. Whether or not this is a plausible explanation/interpretation, I guess I'd have to watch the movie, and see where this man lives. – J.R. Jun 4 '12 at 13:58
@J.R. The movie just says the man comes from the caveman age. It does not show the place he used to live. Speaking of cavemen, I always thought they lived in stone cave. I never thought the caves could be made of earth. – Betty Jun 4 '12 at 14:41
@J.R.: If there's a connection, it is far from obvious and is quite obscure/rare. Cave is not necessarily small enough to be called "hole", and is not necessarily formed in ground/mud/soil. So unless your fox is big enough to carve caves out of stone, I'd say that while "earth" might refer "fox hole", "fox hole" most likely doesn't refer to "cave". – SigTerm Jun 5 '12 at 4:27
@SigTerm: I wasn't voting in the debate on what "Earth" means in the title; I was merely answering your statement that As far as I know "earth" never means "cave"... never anything even remotely resembling "cave", and that you couldn't find any dictionary supporting that explanation. – J.R. Jun 5 '12 at 9:24
@J.R.: My answer says "as far as I know". Which means that although I am not aware of any connection between "earth" and "cave", such connection might exist. I do not claim to know everything about English or any other subject - according to Murphy's law, that'll be unwise. – SigTerm Jun 5 '12 at 19:42
show 1 more comment
up vote 2 down vote

You are all missing the point of the title. First of all, the title does not have the article the directly before Earth. It is "The Man from Earth". Nowhere does it say The Earth. I mention this because some people are debating this point in this thread.

As to the meaning of the title...I believe that it implies that the main character has been around so long, and lived in so many different parts of the world, that he cannot clearly define his existence by a single country, race, or language (i.e. French, German, Spaniard, Arabic, etc). Those countries and customs/languages did not exist 14,000 years ago (which is how old he is). Therefore, the most accurate description of his origins is that he's simply a man that existed on the planet all those years; hence the man from Earth. I think it's a great title.

share|improve this answer
What point are you trying to make in your first paragraph? Is there a nuance dependent on having an article or not? If so, you might want to add this in your answer. I disagree that the title implies the nature of the protagonist (we're all "men (and women) from earth"). Instead, after watching the film one might read additional meaning in the title. In logical terms, "man from earth" doesn't lead me to "ancient, well-traveled being on this planet" (A,WTBotP), but "A,WTBotP" may lead me to "man from earth". – Zairja Nov 2 '12 at 16:21
Yes, we are all men & women from Earth. But all of us can identify with a cultural or geographical identity. The main character from the movie cannot make such an identification. The only thing he has in common with other humans, is that he's from the same planet as us. Even the DVD coverart for this movie shows the main character standing on top of the planet Earth. To me, this indicates that the creators of the movie were implying that this man was from Earth, but not anywhere in particular. – Moe Nov 3 '12 at 1:31
up vote 1 down vote

I can answer part of your question. The inclusion or omission of the article "the" does not clarify the ambiguity. I might say "The bull dozer is a piece of earth moving equipment" or I might say "Being from Earth, it's hard to imagine living anywhere else."

Have you seen the film? Perhaps the context of it will help.

share|improve this answer
Yes, I have seen the film, and as Andrew Leach says, the film does include the eponymous Man as a caveman, but that does not help clarify the ambiguity. – Betty Jun 4 '12 at 12:59
Without seeing the film myself, my inclination is to think that "Earth" in the title is the proper noun as in "The Man from planet Earth" – TecBrat Jun 4 '12 at 14:52
up vote 0 down vote

Regarding inclusion of the article "the" before a proper noun (one capitalized outside of the context of a title): this indicates a particular instance of a class or set. Capitalization (outside of a title), indicates a particular class distinct from the set of all possible things of that designation. In the most general case, the uncapitalized form of the noun indicates either all possible things of that designation, or at least, any non-specific thing of that designation. Thus:

"The man from earth" might mean

  • a man composed of soil or dirt (a golem, a metaphor)

  • a man with an association with soil or dirt (a farmer, a sanitation engineer, a man of lower class)

"The man from Earth" might mean

  • a man from the planet Earth in some other context (i.e., on Mars)

  • a man from any version of the planet Earth in a context where multiple Earths may exist (i.e., polycosm, time travel)

"The man from the Earth" might mean

  • a man from the planet Earth in some other context (i.e., on Mars)

  • a man specifically from the familiar version of the planet Earth in a context where multiple Earths may exist (i.e., polycosm, time travel)

share|improve this answer
Good. What about the "burrow" meaning? What are the possible interpretation with and without "the" if "earth" meanings "burrow"? – Betty Jun 5 '12 at 4:02

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.