Take the 2-minute tour ×
English Language & Usage Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for linguists, etymologists, and serious English language enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

There are words where we say A as Ai, and say A as Ah. First I thought there were some sentences where it sounds better then the other. However, when Koreans say Amen they say it as "Ah-men", and I keep hearing Americans say it as "Ai-men". What is the reason for this?

share|improve this question
    
One preacher I knew said he learned that "amen" is pronounced one way when spoken, and the other when sung. But I forget which was which. –  GEdgar Aug 9 '11 at 17:11
    
Probably Ai-men when spoken, and Ah-men when sung. Atleast its that way in our church. –  Sȱɳɨȼ Ʈħe ǶḝÐɠḝħȱɠ Aug 9 '11 at 17:36
add comment

2 Answers 2

up vote 4 down vote accepted

In most dialects of English, 'a' is normally pronounced either /æ/ or /ɛɪ/, as in "man" and "mane". There are relatively few words where it is pronounced /a/ (as in "ah"), and they tend to vary quite a lot with dialect (eg "pass" and "graph" have that vowel in SE England, but not in most of the English speaking world.)

Normal English spelling rules would make "amen" either /ə'mɛn/ (like "amend"), or else /'ɛɪmən/ or /'ɛɪmɪn/, (a bit like "aiming" , but with "n" at the end rather than "ng").

Presumably because of either its foreign origins or its ceremonial character, this is changed into an unusual pattern for English, with full (unreduced) vowels and with either final stress (US /ɛɪ'mɛn/) or even stress (British /a:mɛn/). Even with the unusual stress pattern, the US version has a more regular vowel /ɛɪ/ and the British a more exotic (and slightly truer to its origins) /a:/. I don't know any particular reason why the two varieties of English should have settled down to different realisations of this word.

Since the English /ɛɪ/ is a result of the great vowel shift, few other languages have a remotely similar vowel for "a"; so one would expect to find /a:/ for the word in places which either have not been influenced particularly by English, or have taken it from British English; and /ɛɪ/ only in places where the word has been adopted from American English.

share|improve this answer
    
I think that letter A pronounced /a/ (as in "ah") is more common than implied here, and is predictable for words where the A is clearly syllable-final and not reduced, as in monosyllables: ma, pa, la, Ra, spa, bra, Dada, ta-ta, Zsa-Zsa; and as in borrowed words and names: Maharaja, baja, kumbaya, fatwa, etc. –  nohat Sep 22 '11 at 20:27
    
@nohat. True. But I don't think it is clearly syllable-final here. –  Colin Fine Sep 23 '11 at 10:51
add comment

It's all due to the nationalities and the pronunciation that is more commonly used in different countries. For example, in South-East Asia, "Amen" is also pronounced "Ah-men". This is because of the fact that "a" in South-East Asia, is (nearly) always pronounced as "Ah". However, Americans tend to pronounce "a" as "ai." British also tend to pronounced "a" as "ah" (depending on the region the speaker came from), but Australians generally say "ai-mmen".

Basically, it's all due to how "a" is usually pronounced in the region, or country, or native-language(especially when English is not the first language of the speaker).

share|improve this answer
    
Now I look at it, I think this answer is quite wrong. I don't think there are many other words which have /ɛɪ/ in America and /a:/ in the UK. There are probably some where US /ɛɪ/ corresponds to UK /æ/ or /ə/ - I can't immediately think of any, but that would be generally consistent with other differences, such as the realisation of final "-i". And what on earth does '"a" in South-East Asia is (nearly) always pronounced as "Ah"' mean? Vietnamese is written in Roman script, it's true, but none of the other languages of continental SE Asia have an "a". –  Colin Fine Aug 10 '11 at 13:43
add comment

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.