Until + tense / “since” or “for”

Question

Is any of these sentences correct?

1. Until I played again 2 months ago, I had not played to this game for 5 years.
2. Until I played again 2 months ago, I had not played to this game since 5 years.
3. Until I played again 2 months ago, I had not played this game for 5 years.
4. Until I played again 2 months ago, I had not played this game since 5 years.

And can I just say, "until 2 months ago" instead of "until I played again 2 months ago"?

Answer 1

The correct sentence is:

Until I played again 2 months ago, I had not played this game for 5 years.

Playing to something is what you do with a talent to something else, normally a person or group of people, for example:

I played [my guitar] to the audience

Doing something since something works for events or milestones, e.g:

I haven't played this game since I broke my arm.

I've been living here since I was five years old.

And yes you can say

Until 2 months ago, I had not played this game for 5 years.

Answer 2

Until I played again 2 months ago, I had not played this game for 5 years

is correct. So too is

Until 2 months ago, I had not played this game for 5 years