English Language & Usage Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for linguists, etymologists, and serious English language enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

The Macquarie Dictionary lists the following pronunciations: butter /ˈbʌtə/, apart /əˈpaːt/ & action /ˈækʃən/. Wiktionary lists them as butter /ˈbʌ.tə/ (RP), apart /əˈpɑː(ɹ)t/ (RP) & action /ˈæk.ʃən/. However, to me they sound like butter /ˈbʌtʌ/, apart /ʌˈpaːt/ or /əˈpaːt/ & action /ˈækʃən/. If I try to pronounce "butter" as /ˈbʌtə/ it sounds weird to me although "action" sounds fine either way. To me the /ə/ sound in "action" is the true schwa sound but "butter" has the same vowel sound twice. Also, the difference between the two vowels in "apart" just sound like a difference in length to me: /ʌˈpʌːt/. (I just noticed that http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Phonetic_Alphabet_chart_for_English_dialects lists [äː] for "palm" and "father" and [ä] for "strut", "run", "won" and "flood" for AuE, so using that my "apart" would become either /äˈpäːt/ or /əˈpäːt/.) Are there any studies showing a split in what is normally considered a single phoneme, or am I just weird :-) ?

share|improve this question

I'm majoring in linguistics and last semester I took a class on the English sound system. What we learned is that unstressed vowels reduce to a schwa in English. We mostly focused on General American since my school is in the USA. The rule may be different in your particular dialect. There were some phonetic transcriptions in that class that I had to disagree with since my dialect (Western NY State) was a little different. One example is that every textbook and professor I've known transcribes the "-ing" ending with a short "i" like the one in "it" in many dialects. Every time I say a gerund or present participle all I hear is a long "i" like in Bastille. So, the general rule states that the unstressed vowels in "butter" and "action" will be schwas. Your individual way of speaking might be an exception. Remember also that as you carefully pronounce a word to yourself you will eliminate schwa sounds because you are trying to hear each vowel carefully. Try to record yourself in natural conversation saying these words. That might reveal to you that you actually do say /ˈbʌtə/.

share|improve this answer
I know what you mean about the transcriptions for -ing words seeming odd. The final [ŋ] nasal changes the vowel that comes before it a bit, so that the vowel in sing is not exactly like the one in sit — nor in seat for that matter. There are no words in English that seem to have a close/high vowel like [iː] or [uː] and then the [ŋ] at the end; nothing like beeng or boong, for example. So it kinda seems like more of a spelling convention. And yet if you compare being with bing and big, you can start to see why they use [ɪŋ] not [iːŋ]. – tchrist Aug 2 '14 at 5:40

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.