Why is the phrase "I hope this computer work" unacceptable? The word "hope" makes the phrase subjunctive, so why isn't it correct to use the infinitive verb form?
- Anybody can ask a question
- Anybody can answer
- The best answers are voted up and rise to the top
is ungrammatical (hence the asterisk, which marks ungrammatical sentences) because it is short for
which is grammatical.
The that complementizer introducing the tensed object complement clause
is optional, and may be deleted, as in the original example.
But this leaves a tensed clause, in the present tense,
The problem is basically that your entire question is based on a false premise. There's no a priori reason to state/expect that '"hope" makes the phrase subjunctive' (which is a nonsensical notion in itself).
The answer to your question is: because.
More seriously, the subjunctive in English is largely a vestigial organ. There are no particularly hard and fast rules that regulate verb usage or tense in English in the way that a Romance language would require.
In other words, in effect there really is no true subjunctive in English, but rather several ways of approximating it.
If translating the subjunctive from a Romance language to English, instead of trying to make our verbs agree with a mood, we merely change things like word order, the verb itself, etc.
Consider one of the few subjunctive uses in English:
There is very little difference in meaning from:
A Romance language would require that this sentence be conjugated differently. But, English doesn't particularly care.
TL;DR You don't need to use the subjunctive in English because there really isn't one.
Different languages have different verbs that require (with varying degrees of strictness) the use of the subjunctive. In English, we do not generally use the subjunctive with the verb hope. Compare the following, (using the verb to be, as it is more clearly distinguished in the subjunctive):
I can imagine that in some languages to hope is connected with a subjunctive clause. But that is no general rule for all languages. English and German don't use a subjunctive after to hope.
In terms of common usage we do see "hope" used without the non-subjunctive mood. But if I want to stress that the "hope" isn't very likely, or that I intend to be sarcastic, the subjunctive mood seems to offer a good alternative where I don't need to go all the way to "wish" which suggests a very unlikely scenario.
protected by Mitch Jan 18 at 17:39
Thank you for your interest in this question.
Because it has attracted low-quality or spam answers that had to be removed, posting an answer now requires 10 reputation on this site.
Would you like to answer one of these unanswered questions instead?