Take the 2-minute tour ×
English Language & Usage Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for linguists, etymologists, and serious English language enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I am trying to come up with a single word that describes the saying "meant to be" in a poetic and prophetic manner (but I am not looking for a fantastical description that talks too much about fate).

Specifically this is referring to a situation where Neil deGrasse Tyson succeeded Carl Sagan as host of the show 'Cosmos'. In Carl Sagan's personal journal, he had mentioned that he had always wanted to meet Neil deGrasse, since he had a lot of respect for him.

Anyway, it was almost "meant to be" that Neil deGrasse would become the next host of Cosoms. The closest word I could think of was "poetic." -- It was very "poetic" that Neil deGrasse would take over as host of Cosmos...but it is not exactly the word I am looking for.

Any suggestions??

share|improve this question
1  
As the answers below show, underlying whatever vocabulary is eventually chosen is the philosophical question of whether we believe there to be an agent or natural force involved. –  Edwin Ashworth Mar 13 at 21:44
    
@Edwin. Interestingly, all the current answers seem to be based on the idea that there is some "higher power" who/which preordained whatever later eventuality came to pass. And of course it's not exactly unknown for theists to cite examples of such things as evidence that their god does indeed move in mysterious ways. But as a fully committed Dawkinista, I'd probably just settle for apposite - apt in the circumstances or in relation to something: –  FumbleFingers Mar 13 at 22:02
1  
It seemeth me specially weird that fate should be a major theme running through a question concerning Carl Sagan and Neil DeGrasse Tyson. –  bye Mar 14 at 3:23
    
Sagan did meet NDT when NDT was 17. He talked about that meeting in the first episode of the new Cosmos series. –  Kristina Lopez Mar 14 at 14:15
    
I'm in agreement with @FumbleFingers - my answer didn't suggest apposite, but it's a good fit for a one-word answer. –  Peter Hanley Mar 14 at 16:00

18 Answers 18

intrinsic

"was the intrinsic choice"

"apposite" as already mentioned is nice but no one knows what that means.

You said it yourself: "prophetic" and "succeeded"

"the prophetic choice"

"the natural successor" "naturally the successor to"

"naturally, the intrinsic prophetic successor"

If I may, why are you looking for a "poetic" word to talk about a scientist? Seams to me you'd want to go all tech on it. However, if you had the chance to ask Neil, he'd probably say use the word that the most people will understand (the golden rule of language\communication) which would be "fated". "destined" is as far as I'd go poetically when speaking about one of the forerunners of science.

fundamental

share|improve this answer

How about "fitting". It was very fitting that this gentleman would be the new host. It has less to do with fate and more to do with skills and background for the position. "Apt", as already mentioned, implies the appropriateness of this occurrence rather than some divine scheme.

share|improve this answer

Apropos. Appropriate to a situation. Meaning that, it was meant to be.

share|improve this answer

foreordained is often used, in a somewhat more mystical or supernatural sense (http://www.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/english/foreordain)

share|improve this answer

Out of respect for what the show is trying to encourage (reason, scientific thinking) I would suggest that it would be entirely inappropriate to use any language that suggests fate, destiny or any other eschatological mechanism -- others here have used language that is suited to the show's themes, like "fitting" "heir apparent"; you could even forgo your instinct to use a single word and write something out more explicitly.

Or you could use the language of evolution and make it clear that while there was a complex chain of historical conditions and events that led to NDT being selected as host, the important factors are the specific attributes he had adapted to thrive in the hostile environment of Broadcast Television.

But that might be too clever, so I'd stick with the former.

share|improve this answer

Perhaps inexorable is suitable here? It literally means something that cannot be prevented, but is more often used to mean something that is 'fated' so to speak. I am not sure if it is exactly what you look for but may help.

share|improve this answer

Given their history together, Neil DeGrasse Tyson was the "fitting, heir apparent" to host the newly revived Cosmos series.

Definition of "heir apparent" from MWO:

heir apparent: noun

1: an heir whose right to receive money, property, or a title cannot be taken away

2: a person who is very likely to have a job or position after the person who has it now leaves

share|improve this answer
    
He's not an heir apparent, he really is presenting the show now. –  Jon Hanna Mar 14 at 14:13
    
Got your point, @JonHanna. I edited my answer. :-) –  Kristina Lopez Mar 14 at 14:23

Ordained, written, preordained, fated, kismet, and the archaic ardane would all match the meaning asked for.

However, none would be particularly appropriate in this case; even in figurative use it would be quite counter to the spirit of the show, and to Sagan's work more generally—"Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence" so where is your evidence that this was "meant" to be?

It would be more fitting perhaps to refer to Tyson as an apt choice.

share|improve this answer

How about "apt"? "It was apt that Neil Degrasse became the next host of Cosmos because Carl Sagan would have wanted it so".

share|improve this answer

Synchronicity, or a variation of.

share|improve this answer

Another possibility would be inevitable:

adj. Impossible to avoid or prevent.

While it does not carry the connotation of fate or any indication of poetry, it is the word I'd use for something that was bound to happen.

share|improve this answer
    
Best said in the voice of Agent Smith –  Charles Goodwin Mar 14 at 15:34

You could try preordained:-

(especially of a power thought to be greater than ordinary people) to decide or fix what will happen in a way that cannot be changed or controlled:

Illness and suffering seemed (to be) preordained to be her lot.

His life seems to have followed a preordained path/direction.

share|improve this answer

You want poetic, you'll get poetic.

Written in the stars: it was destined to happen. The belief that our fate is written in the stars is ancient (horoscopes are a modern use of that belief), and certainly made famous by Shakespear's use in Romeo and Juliet

From forth the fatal loins of these two foes
A pair of star-crossed lovers take their life,
Whose misadventured piteous overthrows
Doth with their death bury their parents’ strife...

Also, preordained: happening inevitably. Connotes a higher power meant for it to be.

all the days ordained for me were written in your book before one of them came to be. - Psalm 139

As the Fates would have it.

share|improve this answer

Kismet sums it all up.

Destiny; fate:

share|improve this answer

'Manifest' might be appropriate.

share|improve this answer
    
Yes!! I really like that one! –  Krypt Mar 13 at 21:44
    
This short answer could be more helpful if you provide a little more detail. For example, you might explain further why you think this word is appropriate, define it, or tell us how you would use it in place of "poetic" in the OP's question. –  aedia λ Mar 13 at 22:07

Fated seems pretty appropriate here. But also destined, preordained, and not one word but 'in the stars seems pretty apropos given the context.

EDIT - added after comment below Leon Conrad

It sounds like you mean that it was appropriate, suitable, felicitous, proper, apt, or, as I used above, apropos.

share|improve this answer
    
Yes! You are dead on. I really like "apropos"...it is very apropos. hah! –  Krypt Mar 13 at 21:45
    
Please mark the answer as correct if you like it. –  James McCormack Mar 14 at 10:31
    
"In the stars" seems particularly inappropriate given the context, unless you suggest that massive, luminous spheres of plasma held together by their own gravity had an effect on the choice. –  Jon Hanna Mar 14 at 14:14

The word you are seeking is 'fate'.

If you believe it was 'meant to happen' that a Malaysian airliner should disappear without trace, then you are a 'fatalist'. You believe that events proceed according to some preordained plan.

share|improve this answer
    
What's upset the phantom this time? –  WS2 Mar 14 at 0:56

How about Predestined or predetermined?

share|improve this answer
    
Actually, I suppose when I mentioned "prophetic" I was misleading, since words such as these are very fantastical. I'm looking for something more like "it was very fitting" or "it was very poetic". If you used words such as "predetermined", you would have to preface it: "it was as if it was predetermined that..." –  Krypt Mar 13 at 21:38

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.