English Language & Usage Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for linguists, etymologists, and serious English language enthusiasts. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

Which one has red color in the following phrase?

the red bottle's lid

the bottle or the lid?


Now I understand the actual sentence with which I am faced.

A more insidious attack strategy is to coerce an unwitting third-party visitor’s browser to send unwanted HTTP requests on the attacker’s behalf, abusing the identity relationship already established between your application and that victim.

share|improve this question
up vote 11 down vote accepted

The red bottle's lid

Normally it would be the bottle that was red. Because "red" stands before "bottle", and "bottle's lid" is not a single compound noun but two separate nouns, the ordinary pattern of [adjective, noun it belongs to, anything else] take precedence over the less frequent pattern [adjective, noun that is the possessor of another noun, head noun to which the adjective belongs].

What kind of a lid do we have here? A red bottle's lid. Ah, but how do you know this lid comes off a red bottle? I see some glass splinters stuck to the lid.

Things change if you are using the first noun as a noun adjective, resulting in a compound noun:

The red bottle lid

In this case, "bottle" is a noun adjective, not simply a regular noun with the possessive s; that makes "bottle lid" a single compound noun. Then "red" belongs to the entire compound noun; and because the final element of a compound noun ("lid") is the head (the "core" of the compound), the adjective mostly describes a property of the head. The lid is red.

What kind of red lid do we have here? A red bottle lid. Ah, right.

The red lid of the bottle

Here "red" simply belongs to the first noun that follows it, because we have no compound noun, merely a prepositional attribute "of the bottle" and a head "lid".

What kind of a red lid do you have there? It is the red lid of the bottle! Huh, of what bottle? Oh, you know, of the bottle you got me drunk with yesterday, in order to have sex with you, which I would otherwise never have subjected myself to? Ah, right.

share|improve this answer

the red bottle's lid

means the bottle is red.

the red bottle lid

means the bottle lid is red.

share|improve this answer
  • “The bottle's red lid” refer to the red lid of a particular bottle
  • “The red bottle's lid” refers to the lid of a red bottle, which is indicated to be uniquely identifiable by its colour (i.e., you can't say that if there is more than one red bottle)
  • “The red bottle lid” refers to a red lid belonging to a bottle; it can also weakly imply that the lid is not currently attached to a particular bottle.
share|improve this answer

The bottle has the red colour in that sentence

the colour of the lid is completely unknown

share|improve this answer

the red bottle's lid = the bottle is red.

If a lid were red = the red bottle lid (or of course, the bottle's red lid if talking specifically about a specific bottle)

share|improve this answer

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.