If it's 7:30pm, which of these phrases is correct, Good night or Good evening?
- Anybody can ask a question
- Anybody can answer
- The best answers are voted up and rise to the top
Depends on context. "Good night" is generally reserved as a replacement for "goodbye". "Good evening" is a form of "hello".
"Good evening" is something that can be used from roughly 5 PM on. "Good night" can also be said from 5 PM on, but usually means one of two things:
It basically never means "hello (late evening)" that equivalent phrases can have in other languages.
My answer from a similar, before someone pointed to this as a related question, to which this is even more suited:
"Good night" as a greeting was once commonly found in Ireland, but almost exclusive to there. In James Joyce's "The Dead", for example, it is used both as greeting:
And as a farewell:
I suspect, but do not know for sure, that this was a retention of something that was more widespread, but died out elsewhere sooner than in Ireland.
In any case, it has mostly died out here too. It may be heard from an older generation, and perhaps lingers in some regions, but my generation (mid 30s) wouldn't use it either in the region I grew up, nor where I now live.
"Good evening" would be the more normal night-time greeting.
The only logical explanation I can think of for our no longer using "good night" in this way, is that it is so often said to someone about to retire to bed, that it was hence used more often as a farewell and then came to have only this meaning. The other forms, after all, would be more often used as a greeting than a farewell, though historically that was not the case.
So far as I know, there is no generally accepted definition of the exact times that evening starts and ends.
As others have said, good night is most often used when parting. If you said this at 7:30 people might respond "goodbye" and turn away.
As you enter the home of a friend, you might say good night to someone leaving and good evening to your host (assuming it isn't the sort of occasion where "wassup hussler" and "yo bitch" are appropriate).
Good evening can be used to say hello or goodbye depending on the context. Good evening can be used to say hello once it gets dark outside and the time varies depending on the season. Good evening can be used to say goodbye usually just after it turns dark outside. Good night is usually used to say goodbye later on at night when people separate for the rest of the evening/night.
As per my knowledge and experience: good morning; good afternoon; good evening; hello etc. to say or greet the person for the first time on that day.
Even if you are meeting a person at 10 p.m. at night, the first time of the day, you can still greet him/her with "Good morning". This means it's a positive, well wishing statement, that's all. As somebody has pointed out already, when two people part company for the rest of the day, then "Good night" is the correct one. (Any comment, please correct me if I am wrong.)
Similarly, dinner is not only for night food, it's just a meal, you can say it in the morning, afternoon or night. But, in this case, it's clear in the morning we say breakfast; afternoon-lunch, and dinner means night :)
protected by tchrist Aug 2 '14 at 14:44
Thank you for your interest in this question.
Because it has attracted low-quality or spam answers that had to be removed, posting an answer now requires 10 reputation on this site (the association bonus does not count).
Would you like to answer one of these unanswered questions instead?